{"oa_version":"None","date_created":"2023-11-19T23:00:54Z","user_id":"2DF688A6-F248-11E8-B48F-1D18A9856A87","publisher":"AAAS","scopus_import":"1","quality_controlled":"1","title":"Plant size, latitude, and phylogeny explain within-population variability in herbivory","status":"public","related_material":{"record":[{"id":"14579","relation":"research_data","status":"public"}]},"type":"journal_article","day":"09","article_processing_charge":"No","month":"11","date_updated":"2023-11-20T11:17:34Z","pmid":1,"publication_status":"published","date_published":"2023-11-09T00:00:00Z","issue":"6671","department":[{"_id":"NiBa"}],"abstract":[{"text":"Interactions between plants and herbivores are central in most ecosystems, but their strength is highly variable. The amount of variability within a system is thought to influence most aspects of plant-herbivore biology, from ecological stability to plant defense evolution. Our understanding of what influences variability, however, is limited by sparse data. We collected standardized surveys of herbivory for 503 plant species at 790 sites across 116° of latitude. With these data, we show that within-population variability in herbivory increases with latitude, decreases with plant size, and is phylogenetically structured. Differences in the magnitude of variability are thus central to how plant-herbivore biology varies across macroscale gradients. We argue that increased focus on interaction variability will advance understanding of patterns of life on Earth.","lang":"eng"}],"intvolume":" 382","volume":382,"year":"2023","acknowledgement":"The authors acknowledge funding for central project coordination from NSF Research Coordination Network grant DEB-2203582; the Ecology, Evolution, and Behavior Program at Michigan State University; and AgBioResearch at Michigan State University. Site-specific funding is listed in the supplementary materials.","publication":"Science","author":[{"full_name":"Robinson, M. L.","last_name":"Robinson","first_name":"M. L."},{"full_name":"Hahn, P. G.","first_name":"P. G.","last_name":"Hahn"},{"last_name":"Inouye","first_name":"B. D.","full_name":"Inouye, B. D."},{"first_name":"N.","last_name":"Underwood","full_name":"Underwood, N."},{"last_name":"Whitehead","first_name":"S. R.","full_name":"Whitehead, S. R."},{"first_name":"K. C.","last_name":"Abbott","full_name":"Abbott, K. C."},{"last_name":"Bruna","first_name":"E. M.","full_name":"Bruna, E. M."},{"last_name":"Cacho","first_name":"N. I.","full_name":"Cacho, N. I."},{"full_name":"Dyer, L. A.","first_name":"L. A.","last_name":"Dyer"},{"full_name":"Abdala-Roberts, L.","first_name":"L.","last_name":"Abdala-Roberts"},{"full_name":"Allen, W. J.","last_name":"Allen","first_name":"W. J."},{"last_name":"Andrade","first_name":"J. F.","full_name":"Andrade, J. F."},{"full_name":"Angulo, D. F.","first_name":"D. F.","last_name":"Angulo"},{"full_name":"Anjos, D.","last_name":"Anjos","first_name":"D."},{"first_name":"D. N.","last_name":"Anstett","full_name":"Anstett, D. N."},{"last_name":"Bagchi","first_name":"R.","full_name":"Bagchi, R."},{"full_name":"Bagchi, S.","last_name":"Bagchi","first_name":"S."},{"full_name":"Barbosa, M.","last_name":"Barbosa","first_name":"M."},{"full_name":"Barrett, S.","last_name":"Barrett","first_name":"S."},{"orcid":"0000-0002-7354-8574","first_name":"Carina","last_name":"Baskett","full_name":"Baskett, Carina","id":"3B4A7CE2-F248-11E8-B48F-1D18A9856A87"},{"full_name":"Ben-Simchon, E.","last_name":"Ben-Simchon","first_name":"E."},{"full_name":"Bloodworth, K. J.","last_name":"Bloodworth","first_name":"K. J."},{"full_name":"Bronstein, J. L.","last_name":"Bronstein","first_name":"J. L."},{"full_name":"Buckley, Y. M.","last_name":"Buckley","first_name":"Y. M."},{"full_name":"Burghardt, K. T.","first_name":"K. T.","last_name":"Burghardt"},{"full_name":"Bustos-Segura, C.","first_name":"C.","last_name":"Bustos-Segura"},{"first_name":"E. S.","last_name":"Calixto","full_name":"Calixto, E. S."},{"last_name":"Carvalho","first_name":"R. L.","full_name":"Carvalho, R. L."},{"full_name":"Castagneyrol, B.","first_name":"B.","last_name":"Castagneyrol"},{"full_name":"Chiuffo, M. C.","first_name":"M. C.","last_name":"Chiuffo"},{"first_name":"D.","last_name":"Cinoğlu","full_name":"Cinoğlu, D."},{"first_name":"E.","last_name":"Cinto Mejía","full_name":"Cinto Mejía, E."},{"last_name":"Cock","first_name":"M. C.","full_name":"Cock, M. C."},{"full_name":"Cogni, R.","first_name":"R.","last_name":"Cogni"},{"full_name":"Cope, O. L.","last_name":"Cope","first_name":"O. L."},{"last_name":"Cornelissen","first_name":"T.","full_name":"Cornelissen, T."},{"full_name":"Cortez, D. R.","last_name":"Cortez","first_name":"D. R."},{"last_name":"Crowder","first_name":"D. W.","full_name":"Crowder, D. W."},{"last_name":"Dallstream","first_name":"C.","full_name":"Dallstream, C."},{"full_name":"Dáttilo, W.","first_name":"W.","last_name":"Dáttilo"},{"last_name":"Davis","first_name":"J. K.","full_name":"Davis, J. K."},{"first_name":"R. D.","last_name":"Dimarco","full_name":"Dimarco, R. D."},{"first_name":"H. E.","last_name":"Dole","full_name":"Dole, H. E."},{"full_name":"Egbon, I. N.","first_name":"I. N.","last_name":"Egbon"},{"full_name":"Eisenring, M.","first_name":"M.","last_name":"Eisenring"},{"full_name":"Ejomah, A.","first_name":"A.","last_name":"Ejomah"},{"first_name":"B. D.","last_name":"Elderd","full_name":"Elderd, B. D."},{"last_name":"Endara","first_name":"M. J.","full_name":"Endara, M. J."},{"last_name":"Eubanks","first_name":"M. D.","full_name":"Eubanks, M. D."},{"full_name":"Everingham, S. E.","first_name":"S. E.","last_name":"Everingham"},{"last_name":"Farah","first_name":"K. N.","full_name":"Farah, K. N."},{"last_name":"Farias","first_name":"R. P.","full_name":"Farias, R. P."},{"last_name":"Fernandes","first_name":"A. P.","full_name":"Fernandes, A. P."},{"last_name":"Fernandes","first_name":"G. W.","full_name":"Fernandes, G. W."},{"full_name":"Ferrante, M.","last_name":"Ferrante","first_name":"M."},{"first_name":"A.","last_name":"Finn","full_name":"Finn, A."},{"last_name":"Florjancic","first_name":"G. A.","full_name":"Florjancic, G. A."},{"first_name":"M. L.","last_name":"Forister","full_name":"Forister, M. L."},{"last_name":"Fox","first_name":"Q. N.","full_name":"Fox, Q. N."},{"full_name":"Frago, E.","last_name":"Frago","first_name":"E."},{"full_name":"França, F. M.","last_name":"França","first_name":"F. M."},{"first_name":"A. S.","last_name":"Getman-Pickering","full_name":"Getman-Pickering, A. S."},{"last_name":"Getman-Pickering","first_name":"Z.","full_name":"Getman-Pickering, Z."},{"full_name":"Gianoli, E.","last_name":"Gianoli","first_name":"E."},{"full_name":"Gooden, B.","last_name":"Gooden","first_name":"B."},{"full_name":"Gossner, M. M.","last_name":"Gossner","first_name":"M. M."},{"last_name":"Greig","first_name":"K. A.","full_name":"Greig, K. A."},{"full_name":"Gripenberg, S.","last_name":"Gripenberg","first_name":"S."},{"full_name":"Groenteman, R.","first_name":"R.","last_name":"Groenteman"},{"full_name":"Grof-Tisza, P.","first_name":"P.","last_name":"Grof-Tisza"},{"full_name":"Haack, N.","last_name":"Haack","first_name":"N."},{"last_name":"Hahn","first_name":"L.","full_name":"Hahn, L."},{"full_name":"Haq, S. M.","last_name":"Haq","first_name":"S. M."},{"last_name":"Helms","first_name":"A. M.","full_name":"Helms, A. M."},{"last_name":"Hennecke","first_name":"J.","full_name":"Hennecke, J."},{"last_name":"Hermann","first_name":"S. L.","full_name":"Hermann, S. L."},{"full_name":"Holeski, L. M.","last_name":"Holeski","first_name":"L. M."},{"first_name":"S.","last_name":"Holm","full_name":"Holm, S."},{"full_name":"Hutchinson, M. C.","last_name":"Hutchinson","first_name":"M. C."},{"last_name":"Jackson","first_name":"E. E.","full_name":"Jackson, E. E."},{"last_name":"Kagiya","first_name":"S.","full_name":"Kagiya, S."},{"full_name":"Kalske, A.","last_name":"Kalske","first_name":"A."},{"full_name":"Kalwajtys, M.","first_name":"M.","last_name":"Kalwajtys"},{"full_name":"Karban, R.","first_name":"R.","last_name":"Karban"},{"first_name":"R.","last_name":"Kariyat","full_name":"Kariyat, R."},{"first_name":"T.","last_name":"Keasar","full_name":"Keasar, T."},{"first_name":"M. F.","last_name":"Kersch-Becker","full_name":"Kersch-Becker, M. F."},{"first_name":"H. M.","last_name":"Kharouba","full_name":"Kharouba, H. M."},{"last_name":"Kim","first_name":"T. N.","full_name":"Kim, T. N."},{"full_name":"Kimuyu, D. M.","first_name":"D. M.","last_name":"Kimuyu"},{"full_name":"Kluse, J.","first_name":"J.","last_name":"Kluse"},{"last_name":"Koerner","first_name":"S. E.","full_name":"Koerner, S. E."},{"last_name":"Komatsu","first_name":"K. J.","full_name":"Komatsu, K. J."},{"full_name":"Krishnan, S.","first_name":"S.","last_name":"Krishnan"},{"last_name":"Laihonen","first_name":"M.","full_name":"Laihonen, M."},{"full_name":"Lamelas-López, L.","last_name":"Lamelas-López","first_name":"L."},{"last_name":"Lascaleia","first_name":"M. C.","full_name":"Lascaleia, M. C."},{"last_name":"Lecomte","first_name":"N.","full_name":"Lecomte, N."},{"full_name":"Lehn, C. R.","last_name":"Lehn","first_name":"C. R."},{"full_name":"Li, X.","last_name":"Li","first_name":"X."},{"full_name":"Lindroth, R. L.","first_name":"R. L.","last_name":"Lindroth"},{"full_name":"Lopresti, E. F.","first_name":"E. F.","last_name":"Lopresti"},{"full_name":"Losada, M.","first_name":"M.","last_name":"Losada"},{"first_name":"A. M.","last_name":"Louthan","full_name":"Louthan, A. M."},{"full_name":"Luizzi, V. J.","first_name":"V. J.","last_name":"Luizzi"},{"last_name":"Lynch","first_name":"S. C.","full_name":"Lynch, S. C."},{"full_name":"Lynn, J. S.","first_name":"J. S.","last_name":"Lynn"},{"last_name":"Lyon","first_name":"N. J.","full_name":"Lyon, N. J."},{"last_name":"Maia","first_name":"L. F.","full_name":"Maia, L. F."},{"last_name":"Maia","first_name":"R. A.","full_name":"Maia, R. A."},{"full_name":"Mannall, T. L.","first_name":"T. L.","last_name":"Mannall"},{"last_name":"Martin","first_name":"B. S.","full_name":"Martin, B. S."},{"full_name":"Massad, T. J.","last_name":"Massad","first_name":"T. J."},{"first_name":"A. C.","last_name":"Mccall","full_name":"Mccall, A. C."},{"last_name":"Mcgurrin","first_name":"K.","full_name":"Mcgurrin, K."},{"full_name":"Merwin, A. C.","first_name":"A. C.","last_name":"Merwin"},{"full_name":"Mijango-Ramos, Z.","last_name":"Mijango-Ramos","first_name":"Z."},{"full_name":"Mills, C. H.","last_name":"Mills","first_name":"C. H."},{"full_name":"Moles, A. T.","first_name":"A. T.","last_name":"Moles"},{"full_name":"Moore, C. M.","first_name":"C. M.","last_name":"Moore"},{"first_name":"X.","last_name":"Moreira","full_name":"Moreira, X."},{"full_name":"Morrison, C. R.","last_name":"Morrison","first_name":"C. R."},{"last_name":"Moshobane","first_name":"M. C.","full_name":"Moshobane, M. C."},{"last_name":"Muola","first_name":"A.","full_name":"Muola, A."},{"last_name":"Nakadai","first_name":"R.","full_name":"Nakadai, R."},{"full_name":"Nakajima, K.","first_name":"K.","last_name":"Nakajima"},{"last_name":"Novais","first_name":"S.","full_name":"Novais, S."},{"first_name":"C. O.","last_name":"Ogbebor","full_name":"Ogbebor, C. O."},{"full_name":"Ohsaki, H.","first_name":"H.","last_name":"Ohsaki"},{"full_name":"Pan, V. S.","last_name":"Pan","first_name":"V. S."},{"first_name":"N. A.","last_name":"Pardikes","full_name":"Pardikes, N. A."},{"full_name":"Pareja, M.","first_name":"M.","last_name":"Pareja"},{"full_name":"Parthasarathy, N.","first_name":"N.","last_name":"Parthasarathy"},{"first_name":"R. R.","last_name":"Pawar","full_name":"Pawar, R. R."},{"full_name":"Paynter, Q.","first_name":"Q.","last_name":"Paynter"},{"last_name":"Pearse","first_name":"I. S.","full_name":"Pearse, I. S."},{"last_name":"Penczykowski","first_name":"R. M.","full_name":"Penczykowski, R. M."},{"full_name":"Pepi, A. A.","last_name":"Pepi","first_name":"A. A."},{"first_name":"C. C.","last_name":"Pereira","full_name":"Pereira, C. C."},{"last_name":"Phartyal","first_name":"S. S.","full_name":"Phartyal, S. S."},{"last_name":"Piper","first_name":"F. I.","full_name":"Piper, F. I."},{"full_name":"Poveda, K.","first_name":"K.","last_name":"Poveda"},{"first_name":"E. G.","last_name":"Pringle","full_name":"Pringle, E. G."},{"full_name":"Puy, J.","last_name":"Puy","first_name":"J."},{"full_name":"Quijano, T.","last_name":"Quijano","first_name":"T."},{"full_name":"Quintero, C.","last_name":"Quintero","first_name":"C."},{"full_name":"Rasmann, S.","last_name":"Rasmann","first_name":"S."},{"full_name":"Rosche, C.","first_name":"C.","last_name":"Rosche"},{"first_name":"L. Y.","last_name":"Rosenheim","full_name":"Rosenheim, L. Y."},{"last_name":"Rosenheim","first_name":"J. A.","full_name":"Rosenheim, J. A."},{"first_name":"J. B.","last_name":"Runyon","full_name":"Runyon, J. B."},{"last_name":"Sadeh","first_name":"A.","full_name":"Sadeh, A."},{"first_name":"Y.","last_name":"Sakata","full_name":"Sakata, Y."},{"first_name":"D. M.","last_name":"Salcido","full_name":"Salcido, D. M."},{"full_name":"Salgado-Luarte, C.","last_name":"Salgado-Luarte","first_name":"C."},{"last_name":"Santos","first_name":"B. A.","full_name":"Santos, B. A."},{"full_name":"Sapir, Y.","first_name":"Y.","last_name":"Sapir"},{"full_name":"Sasal, Y.","last_name":"Sasal","first_name":"Y."},{"first_name":"Y.","last_name":"Sato","full_name":"Sato, Y."},{"last_name":"Sawant","first_name":"M.","full_name":"Sawant, M."},{"full_name":"Schroeder, H.","first_name":"H.","last_name":"Schroeder"},{"first_name":"I.","last_name":"Schumann","full_name":"Schumann, I."},{"full_name":"Segoli, M.","first_name":"M.","last_name":"Segoli"},{"first_name":"H.","last_name":"Segre","full_name":"Segre, H."},{"first_name":"O.","last_name":"Shelef","full_name":"Shelef, O."},{"last_name":"Shinohara","first_name":"N.","full_name":"Shinohara, N."},{"full_name":"Singh, R. P.","last_name":"Singh","first_name":"R. P."},{"full_name":"Smith, D. S.","first_name":"D. S.","last_name":"Smith"},{"first_name":"M.","last_name":"Sobral","full_name":"Sobral, M."},{"full_name":"Stotz, G. C.","first_name":"G. C.","last_name":"Stotz"},{"full_name":"Tack, A. J.M.","last_name":"Tack","first_name":"A. J.M."},{"full_name":"Tayal, M.","first_name":"M.","last_name":"Tayal"},{"first_name":"J. F.","last_name":"Tooker","full_name":"Tooker, J. F."},{"full_name":"Torrico-Bazoberry, D.","first_name":"D.","last_name":"Torrico-Bazoberry"},{"full_name":"Tougeron, K.","first_name":"K.","last_name":"Tougeron"},{"full_name":"Trowbridge, A. M.","last_name":"Trowbridge","first_name":"A. M."},{"full_name":"Utsumi, S.","first_name":"S.","last_name":"Utsumi"},{"full_name":"Uyi, O.","last_name":"Uyi","first_name":"O."},{"first_name":"J. L.","last_name":"Vaca-Uribe","full_name":"Vaca-Uribe, J. L."},{"last_name":"Valtonen","first_name":"A.","full_name":"Valtonen, A."},{"full_name":"Van Dijk, L. J.A.","first_name":"L. J.A.","last_name":"Van Dijk"},{"last_name":"Vandvik","first_name":"V.","full_name":"Vandvik, V."},{"first_name":"J.","last_name":"Villellas","full_name":"Villellas, J."},{"full_name":"Waller, L. P.","last_name":"Waller","first_name":"L. P."},{"full_name":"Weber, M. G.","first_name":"M. G.","last_name":"Weber"},{"full_name":"Yamawo, A.","first_name":"A.","last_name":"Yamawo"},{"first_name":"S.","last_name":"Yim","full_name":"Yim, S."},{"full_name":"Zarnetske, P. L.","last_name":"Zarnetske","first_name":"P. L."},{"full_name":"Zehr, L. N.","first_name":"L. N.","last_name":"Zehr"},{"last_name":"Zhong","first_name":"Z.","full_name":"Zhong, Z."},{"last_name":"Wetzel","first_name":"W. C.","full_name":"Wetzel, W. C."}],"doi":"10.1126/science.adh8830","page":"679-683","external_id":{"pmid":["37943897"]},"publication_identifier":{"eissn":["1095-9203"]},"article_type":"original","citation":{"mla":"Robinson, M. L., et al. “Plant Size, Latitude, and Phylogeny Explain within-Population Variability in Herbivory.” Science, vol. 382, no. 6671, AAAS, 2023, pp. 679–83, doi:10.1126/science.adh8830.","ieee":"M. L. Robinson et al., “Plant size, latitude, and phylogeny explain within-population variability in herbivory,” Science, vol. 382, no. 6671. AAAS, pp. 679–683, 2023.","chicago":"Robinson, M. L., P. G. Hahn, B. D. Inouye, N. Underwood, S. R. Whitehead, K. C. Abbott, E. M. Bruna, et al. “Plant Size, Latitude, and Phylogeny Explain within-Population Variability in Herbivory.” Science. AAAS, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adh8830.","apa":"Robinson, M. L., Hahn, P. G., Inouye, B. D., Underwood, N., Whitehead, S. R., Abbott, K. C., … Wetzel, W. C. (2023). Plant size, latitude, and phylogeny explain within-population variability in herbivory. Science. AAAS. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adh8830","ista":"Robinson ML et al. 2023. Plant size, latitude, and phylogeny explain within-population variability in herbivory. Science. 382(6671), 679–683.","ama":"Robinson ML, Hahn PG, Inouye BD, et al. Plant size, latitude, and phylogeny explain within-population variability in herbivory. Science. 2023;382(6671):679-683. doi:10.1126/science.adh8830","short":"M.L. Robinson, P.G. Hahn, B.D. Inouye, N. Underwood, S.R. Whitehead, K.C. Abbott, E.M. Bruna, N.I. Cacho, L.A. Dyer, L. Abdala-Roberts, W.J. Allen, J.F. Andrade, D.F. Angulo, D. Anjos, D.N. Anstett, R. Bagchi, S. Bagchi, M. Barbosa, S. Barrett, C. Baskett, E. Ben-Simchon, K.J. Bloodworth, J.L. Bronstein, Y.M. Buckley, K.T. Burghardt, C. Bustos-Segura, E.S. Calixto, R.L. Carvalho, B. Castagneyrol, M.C. Chiuffo, D. Cinoğlu, E. Cinto Mejía, M.C. Cock, R. Cogni, O.L. Cope, T. Cornelissen, D.R. Cortez, D.W. Crowder, C. Dallstream, W. Dáttilo, J.K. Davis, R.D. Dimarco, H.E. Dole, I.N. Egbon, M. Eisenring, A. Ejomah, B.D. Elderd, M.J. Endara, M.D. Eubanks, S.E. Everingham, K.N. Farah, R.P. Farias, A.P. Fernandes, G.W. Fernandes, M. Ferrante, A. Finn, G.A. Florjancic, M.L. Forister, Q.N. Fox, E. Frago, F.M. França, A.S. Getman-Pickering, Z. Getman-Pickering, E. Gianoli, B. Gooden, M.M. Gossner, K.A. Greig, S. Gripenberg, R. Groenteman, P. Grof-Tisza, N. Haack, L. Hahn, S.M. Haq, A.M. Helms, J. Hennecke, S.L. Hermann, L.M. Holeski, S. Holm, M.C. Hutchinson, E.E. Jackson, S. Kagiya, A. Kalske, M. Kalwajtys, R. Karban, R. Kariyat, T. Keasar, M.F. Kersch-Becker, H.M. Kharouba, T.N. Kim, D.M. Kimuyu, J. Kluse, S.E. Koerner, K.J. Komatsu, S. Krishnan, M. Laihonen, L. Lamelas-López, M.C. Lascaleia, N. Lecomte, C.R. Lehn, X. Li, R.L. Lindroth, E.F. Lopresti, M. Losada, A.M. Louthan, V.J. Luizzi, S.C. Lynch, J.S. Lynn, N.J. Lyon, L.F. Maia, R.A. Maia, T.L. Mannall, B.S. Martin, T.J. Massad, A.C. Mccall, K. Mcgurrin, A.C. Merwin, Z. Mijango-Ramos, C.H. Mills, A.T. Moles, C.M. Moore, X. Moreira, C.R. Morrison, M.C. Moshobane, A. Muola, R. Nakadai, K. Nakajima, S. Novais, C.O. Ogbebor, H. Ohsaki, V.S. Pan, N.A. Pardikes, M. Pareja, N. Parthasarathy, R.R. Pawar, Q. Paynter, I.S. Pearse, R.M. Penczykowski, A.A. Pepi, C.C. Pereira, S.S. Phartyal, F.I. Piper, K. Poveda, E.G. Pringle, J. Puy, T. Quijano, C. Quintero, S. Rasmann, C. Rosche, L.Y. Rosenheim, J.A. Rosenheim, J.B. Runyon, A. Sadeh, Y. Sakata, D.M. Salcido, C. Salgado-Luarte, B.A. Santos, Y. Sapir, Y. Sasal, Y. Sato, M. Sawant, H. Schroeder, I. Schumann, M. Segoli, H. Segre, O. Shelef, N. Shinohara, R.P. Singh, D.S. Smith, M. Sobral, G.C. Stotz, A.J.M. Tack, M. Tayal, J.F. Tooker, D. Torrico-Bazoberry, K. Tougeron, A.M. Trowbridge, S. Utsumi, O. Uyi, J.L. Vaca-Uribe, A. Valtonen, L.J.A. Van Dijk, V. Vandvik, J. Villellas, L.P. Waller, M.G. Weber, A. Yamawo, S. Yim, P.L. Zarnetske, L.N. Zehr, Z. Zhong, W.C. Wetzel, Science 382 (2023) 679–683."},"_id":"14552","language":[{"iso":"eng"}]}